When the drought came and the fields decayed into a wasteland, the people had little to say and little energy with which to say it. In the end, they could not speak at all. Silence had come, and the deaf had powers to communicate, their hands dancing, that all others had to learn if they wished to see the further days. But learn, they would not.
Met usually with fear or, at least, suspicion, the old men who lived in cabins in the darker parts of the woods were the only ones with voices left. They had learned to live more off the land, and so maintained their strength – misplaced though it was, in men said to be wandering there for at least a century. It was not really, though, their skill in finding hidden streams or knowing what could be caught or foraged safely, that allowed them to keep their voices.
These were the men who ate the songbirds. In so doing, they took the gift of these smallest creatures for their own, singing and whistling and speaking freely, if only the others would listen.
The people believed the birds were precious, and the cabinmen vicious. Perhaps they were right, indeed, on both matters. But those hidden dwellers knew, and would say given the chance, that drought would always come, and the capture and consumption of songbirds would be necessary for living on.
They would not tell the silent people, though, for this land was not theirs to keep, undeserving as they were for having failed to learn the handspeak of those who never heard or spoke at all. This was the way, every time. Nothing learned.
This barren land was a punishment. People would return, and so too would the driest times. Death, then. Only the men of the cabins would remain, and the songbirds would sing, and then sing no more, until the next time.